Walmart Inc.
Walmart is executing well, but 38.98x earnings for a business guiding FY27 EPS of $2.75-$2.85 leaves too little upside and too much valuation risk at $107.98.
Walmart is a better business than the stock setup. That distinction matters here. The company has improved mix, execution, and digital economics in ways that deserve respect: eCommerce grew 24%, advertising grew 37% globally, membership income rose 15%+, inventory grew only 2.6% against sales growth near 5%, and management says U.S. eCommerce was profitable in all four quarters. This is not the old Walmart debate about whether digital can ever earn money. It can, and management has real proof.
The problem is price. At $107.98, investors are paying 38.98x FY2026 EPS of $2.74 for a company guiding FY27 EPS to only $2.75-$2.85. Even if operating income grows at the high end of 6%-8%, the stock still sits near 38x guided earnings. That multiple might be defensible for a software-like margin structure or a business with accelerating EPS growth, but Walmart still runs at 4.3% operating margin and 2.9% net margin. The market is paying up now for margin expansion that is still gradual at the consolidated level.
The bear case does not require a broken company. It only requires a market that becomes less willing to pay nearly 39x earnings for a defensive retailer in a world with the 10-year Treasury at 5.18% and a positively sloped 2s10s curve of +0.31%. Higher rates generally punish long-duration equity stories, and at this valuation Walmart has become more duration-sensitive than many investors admit. The quality-adjusted and DCF methods in the quant work, $101.07 and $106.15, are notably above the P/E-based value of $45.87, which tells the story cleanly: the business quality is carrying the stock, not the earnings multiple.
What the case depends on is simple. First, valuation has to matter again. Second, the margin gains from ads, membership, marketplace, and automation must remain incremental rather than explosive. Third, management's conservatism has to stay just that, conservatism, not the start of a stronger-than-expected reacceleration. Walmart is a high-class operator. It is not a high-growth company. At this price, the stock is being treated like both.
Ads, membership, marketplace, and automation drive upside to the 6%-8% OI growth guide and sustain a premium multiple despite rising-rate pressure.
Operations remain sound, but valuation normalizes as investors pay less than 38.98x for a company growing sales 3.5%-4.5% and EPS only modestly.
Forward multiple compresses toward high-20s as EPS stays near the low end of $2.75-$2.85 and margin gains are offset by pharmacy and consumer mix pressure.
Quant call (HOLD) diverges from analyst consensus (Strong Buy: 17 buy / 2 hold / 0 sell) — resolve explicitly.
It never was my thinking that made the big money for me. It always was my sitting.
FY27 earnings power looks solid but not strong enough for the current price. On management's $2.75-$2.85 EPS guide, the stock trades around 38x forward earnings, barely below the trailing 38.98x, so the market is already capitalizing several more years of clean execution. The moat is better than it was 3 to 5 years ago because Walmart now combines scale retail, profitable eCommerce, ads, membership, data, and marketplace assets, and AI should help demand forecasting, ad targeting, search, and labor productivity more than it threatens the core store network. That said, the next leg of value creation still depends on turning those advantages into materially higher consolidated margins than 4.3%, and the evidence so far is progress, not transformation.
- Valuation is stretched at 38.98x P/E versus 23.0x for peers, despite FY2026 EPS growth of only 2.6% and FY27 EPS guidance of $2.75-$2.85.
- Operations are improving, with Q4 revenue +4.9% cc, eCommerce +24%, and adjusted operating income +10.5% cc, but that strength has not translated into a meaningfully higher consolidated margin, with FY2026 operating margin still 4.3%.
- The stock has already de-rated from $135.16 but remains expensive at $107.98, only 8.9% below the 200-day average and still above the engine's $89.12 price target.
- Management guided FY27 sales +3.5%-4.5% and operating income +6%-8%, implying profit growth ahead of sales as mix shifts toward higher-margin digital, ads, and membership.
- Higher-quality revenue streams are scaling fast, with advertising +37% globally, Walmart Connect +41%, and membership income +15%+, which supports margin durability beyond pure retail spread.
- Execution has been consistently solid, with 7 beats and 1 miss in the last 8 reported quarters, including the latest +9.2% EPS beat on 2026-08-20.
- Automation is moving from promise to operating reality, with about 60% of U.S. stores receiving some freight from automated DCs and about 50% of eCommerce FC volume automated, while inventory rose only 2.6% against sales growth near 5%.
- The valuation asks too much: 38.98x P/E on FY2026 EPS of $2.74 and roughly 37.9x-39.3x on FY27 guided EPS of $2.75-$2.85, versus 23.0x peer average.
- Core profitability remains thin for the multiple, with FY2026 operating margin at just 4.3% and net margin 2.9%, while Q4 EBITDA margin was only 5.5%, down 150 bps versus Q3 and 220 bps versus Q2.
- Management flagged a regulatory hit, with maximum fair pricing legislation creating an approximately 100 bps sales headwind for FY27 in pharmacy.
- Balance-sheet and cash-flow quality are not elite relative to valuation, with current ratio 0.77, Debt/EBITDA 1.59, FCF $7.5B, and internal cash-flow quality score only 11/100.
| Metric | Value | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Current price | $107.98 | Reference point for target and scenario analysis |
| Quant price target | $89.12 | -17.5% vs current, Low confidence, basis earnings_growth_blend |
| FY2026 revenue | $713.2B | +3.6% YoY, steady growth but not high-growth |
| FY2026 EPS | $2.74 | +2.6% YoY, slower than the valuation implies |
| Operating margin | 4.3% | Flat versus prior FY despite digital and mix improvements |
| Net margin | 2.9% | Thin margin profile for a 38.98x P/E stock |
| P/E | 38.98x | Well above peer average 23.0x |
| P/S | 1.17x | Below peer average 1.4x, reflecting low-margin retail model |
| FY27 guidance | Sales +3.5%-4.5%, OI +6%-8%, EPS $2.75-$2.85 | Guidance points to profit growth ahead of sales, but only modest EPS growth |
| Leverage | Debt/EBITDA 1.59x | Manageable, but not enough to offset valuation risk |
| Free cash flow | $7.5B | Supports capex, dividend, and buybacks, though cash-flow quality score is weak |
| 52-week position | -20.1% vs high, -8.9% vs 200-day average | The stock has corrected, but not enough to create obvious value |
The biggest risk to a bearish stance is that Walmart sustains 6%-8% operating income growth and convinces the market that ads, membership, and profitable eCommerce deserve a structurally higher multiple than the 23.0x peer average.
Next catalyst is earnings on November 19, 2026, especially whether Q1 FY27 operating income lands above the guided 4%-6% range and whether management lifts the conservative full-year posture.
Ownership is institutionally heavy, with the top three institutions holding 34.6%, while insiders own 6.5%, which usually dampens extreme dislocations. Short interest is only 1.84%, or 80.6M shares with 3.3 days-to-cover, so there is little fuel for a squeeze-driven upside reset. Options positioning is supportive near term, with a positive GEX regime and zero-gamma at $103.61, about 4.42% below spot, which can cushion volatility but does not change the valuation argument.
Largest earnings engine; U.S. eCommerce was profitable in all four quarters, with management citing double-digit incremental margins.
Digital and marketplace optionality matter here, with recent news pointing to Google testing Walmart-owned Flipkart purchases through Gemini and AI Mode in India.
Membership and credit-card usage remain a growth vector, helping mix shift toward recurring, higher-margin revenue.
Not separately disclosed in the data provided, but growth is strong, with advertising +37% globally, Walmart Connect +41%, and membership income +15%+.
Walmart guided FY27 to sales +3.5%-4.5% and OI +6%-8% with continued eCommerce-led margin expansion.
Management has earned credibility. On the 2025 Q1 call, the company guided Q2 sales to 3.5%-4.5%, Q2 operating income to 3.0%-4.5%, and said FY results should come in at the high end or slightly above prior ranges after a quarter where sales grew 5.7% cc and adjusted operating income rose 12.9% cc. Since then, Walmart has posted 7 beats and 1 miss over eight quarters, including the latest 0.81 EPS versus 0.742 expected, and the strategic pillars discussed then have largely been delivered: automation is still on track, higher-margin newer businesses are scaling, and U.S. eCommerce has moved from improving economics to profitability in all four quarters. The major change versus two years ago is not direction but maturity, because what was a margin-improvement plan in 2025 is now embedded in FY27 guidance for operating income +6%-8% and acknowledged profitable digital economics.
Full year constant currency sales are expected to grow between 3.5% and 4.5% and operating income is expected to grow between 6% and 8%, with EPS in the range of $2.75 to $2.85.
In Q1, we expect constant currency growth in sales of 3.5% to 4.5% and operating income of 4% to 6% with EPS of $0.63 to $0.65.
Our goal is to outperform this guidance, but we believe it's prudent to start the year with a level of conservatism given the backdrop is still somewhat unstable.
Looking at our results for the quarter, revenue was up 4.9% in constant currency, including growth in eCommerce of 24%. Adjusted operating income grew even faster at 10.5%.
We've far surpassed the breakeven level. We were profitable in each of the 4 quarters in the U.S. segment, and the momentum is only upward from here.
Walmart's moat is still built on scale, price perception, procurement leverage, and store density, but it is broader now because the company can spread fulfillment, data, and ad-tech costs over $713.2B of revenue. The moat looks more durable than it did a few years ago because eCommerce is no longer a pure drag, with U.S. eCommerce profitable in all four quarters and automation already touching about 60% of U.S. stores through automated DC freight and about 50% of eCommerce FC volume. The weak point is that consolidated margins remain low, so the moat protects volume and relevance more clearly than it protects high returns on each dollar of sales.
Capital allocation looks disciplined but not especially aggressive. In the latest data, Walmart generated $7.5B of FCF, spent $7.5B on capex, returned $3.0B in buybacks, and paid $2.0B in dividends, while management guides capex at about 3.5% of sales for FY27. The new $30B repurchase authorization is a vote of confidence, but at nearly 39x earnings buybacks are less value-creating than continued investment in automation, supply chain, and higher-margin digital businesses.
Walmart rates SELL, Medium conviction. The company is executing well, the moat is improving, and management has earned credibility, but the stock still discounts too much of that progress at 38.98x earnings and roughly 38x guided FY27 EPS. This is not a call against the business. It is a call against paying a growth-stock multiple for a company still producing 4.3% operating margins and mid-single-digit sales growth. A move closer to the $89.12 base value, or evidence that consolidated margins can rise meaningfully above current levels, would change the view.
≣ Full research note tap to expand
Executive Summary
SELL, Medium conviction. Rated SELL, Medium conviction. The business is better than it was two years ago, with eCommerce +24%, advertising up 37% globally, and U.S. eCommerce profitable in all four quarters, but the stock still trades at 38.98x FY2026 EPS versus a 23.0x peer average while management only guides FY27 EPS to $2.75-$2.85. With the shares still only 20.1% below the 52-week high and the quant engine's base value at $89.12, the setup looks like solid operations already priced beyond reasonable forward earnings power.
Investment Thesis
Walmart is a better business than the stock setup. That distinction matters here. The company has improved mix, execution, and digital economics in ways that deserve respect: eCommerce grew 24%, advertising grew 37% globally, membership income rose 15%+, inventory grew only 2.6% against sales growth near 5%, and management says U.S. eCommerce was profitable in all four quarters. This is not the old Walmart debate about whether digital can ever earn money. It can, and management has real proof.
The problem is price. At $107.98, investors are paying 38.98x FY2026 EPS of $2.74 for a company guiding FY27 EPS to only $2.75-$2.85. Even if operating income grows at the high end of 6%-8%, the stock still sits near 38x guided earnings. That multiple might be defensible for a software-like margin structure or a business with accelerating EPS growth, but Walmart still runs at 4.3% operating margin and 2.9% net margin. The market is paying up now for margin expansion that is still gradual at the consolidated level.
The bear case does not require a broken company. It only requires a market that becomes less willing to pay nearly 39x earnings for a defensive retailer in a world with the 10-year Treasury at 5.18% and a positively sloped 2s10s curve of +0.31%. Higher rates generally punish long-duration equity stories, and at this valuation Walmart has become more duration-sensitive than many investors admit. The quality-adjusted and DCF methods in the quant work, $101.07 and $106.15, are notably above the P/E-based value of $45.87, which tells the story cleanly: the business quality is carrying the stock, not the earnings multiple.
What the case depends on is simple. First, valuation has to matter again. Second, the margin gains from ads, membership, marketplace, and automation must remain incremental rather than explosive. Third, management's conservatism has to stay just that, conservatism, not the start of a stronger-than-expected reacceleration. Walmart is a high-class operator. It is not a high-growth company. At this price, the stock is being treated like both.
Key Metrics
| Metric | Value | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Current price | $107.98 | Reference point for target and scenario analysis |
| Quant price target | $89.12 | -17.5% vs current, Low confidence, basis earnings_growth_blend |
| FY2026 revenue | $713.2B | +3.6% YoY, steady growth but not high-growth |
| FY2026 EPS | $2.74 | +2.6% YoY, slower than the valuation implies |
| Operating margin | 4.3% | Flat versus prior FY despite digital and mix improvements |
| Net margin | 2.9% | Thin margin profile for a 38.98x P/E stock |
| P/E | 38.98x | Well above peer average 23.0x |
| P/S | 1.17x | Below peer average 1.4x, reflecting low-margin retail model |
| FY27 guidance | Sales +3.5%-4.5%, OI +6%-8%, EPS $2.75-$2.85 | Guidance points to profit growth ahead of sales, but only modest EPS growth |
| Leverage | Debt/EBITDA 1.59x | Manageable, but not enough to offset valuation risk |
| Free cash flow | $7.5B | Supports capex, dividend, and buybacks, though cash-flow quality score is weak |
| 52-week position | -20.1% vs high, -8.9% vs 200-day average | The stock has corrected, but not enough to create obvious value |
Financial Strength
The balance sheet is serviceable rather than pristine. Debt/Equity of 0.75 and Debt/EBITDA of 1.59 are manageable for a retailer of this scale, but the 0.77 current ratio and low internal Financial Health 34/100 and Cash Flow Quality 11/100 scores argue against treating Walmart as a fortress that deserves any valuation. Cash generation is real, with $7.5B of FCF, but consolidated profitability remains thin, and the core question is not solvency but whether modest margin improvement can justify a premium multiple in a higher-rate market.
Competitive Position
Walmart's moat is still built on scale, price perception, procurement leverage, and store density, but it is broader now because the company can spread fulfillment, data, and ad-tech costs over $713.2B of revenue. The moat looks more durable than it did a few years ago because eCommerce is no longer a pure drag, with U.S. eCommerce profitable in all four quarters and automation already touching about 60% of U.S. stores through automated DC freight and about 50% of eCommerce FC volume. The weak point is that consolidated margins remain low, so the moat protects volume and relevance more clearly than it protects high returns on each dollar of sales.
Management & Guidance
Management's FY27 guide is deliberately cautious but directionally positive. CFO John Rainey said, "Full year constant currency sales are expected to grow between 3.5% and 4.5% and operating income is expected to grow between 6% and 8%, with EPS in the range of $2.75 to $2.85." He also said, "Our goal is to outperform this guidance, but we believe it's prudent to start the year with a level of conservatism given the backdrop is still somewhat unstable." That posture is credible given Walmart's beat history, but investors should notice that even a beat from this base still leaves the stock priced richly unless margin expansion accelerates beyond the current trajectory.
Segment Analysis
- Walmart U.S. (N/A): Largest earnings engine; U.S. eCommerce was profitable in all four quarters, with management citing double-digit incremental margins.
- Walmart International (N/A): Digital and marketplace optionality matter here, with recent news pointing to Google testing Walmart-owned Flipkart purchases through Gemini and AI Mode in India.
- Sam's Club (N/A): Membership and credit-card usage remain a growth vector, helping mix shift toward recurring, higher-margin revenue.
- Advertising, membership, marketplace, data services (N/A): Not separately disclosed in the data provided, but growth is strong, with advertising +37% globally, Walmart Connect +41%, and membership income +15%+.
Capital Allocation
Capital allocation looks disciplined but not especially aggressive. In the latest data, Walmart generated $7.5B of FCF, spent $7.5B on capex, returned $3.0B in buybacks, and paid $2.0B in dividends, while management guides capex at about 3.5% of sales for FY27. The new $30B repurchase authorization is a vote of confidence, but at nearly 39x earnings buybacks are less value-creating than continued investment in automation, supply chain, and higher-margin digital businesses.
Management Execution & Track Record
Management has earned credibility. On the 2025 Q1 call, the company guided Q2 sales to 3.5%-4.5%, Q2 operating income to 3.0%-4.5%, and said FY results should come in at the high end or slightly above prior ranges after a quarter where sales grew 5.7% cc and adjusted operating income rose 12.9% cc. Since then, Walmart has posted 7 beats and 1 miss over eight quarters, including the latest 0.81 EPS versus 0.742 expected, and the strategic pillars discussed then have largely been delivered: automation is still on track, higher-margin newer businesses are scaling, and U.S. eCommerce has moved from improving economics to profitability in all four quarters. The major change versus two years ago is not direction but maturity, because what was a margin-improvement plan in 2025 is now embedded in FY27 guidance for operating income +6%-8% and acknowledged profitable digital economics.
Positioning & Flows
Ownership is institutionally heavy, with the top three institutions holding 34.6%, while insiders own 6.5%, which usually dampens extreme dislocations. Short interest is only 1.84%, or 80.6M shares with 3.3 days-to-cover, so there is little fuel for a squeeze-driven upside reset. Options positioning is supportive near term, with a positive GEX regime and zero-gamma at $103.61, about 4.42% below spot, which can cushion volatility but does not change the valuation argument.
Bull Case
- Management guided FY27 sales +3.5%-4.5% and operating income +6%-8%, implying profit growth ahead of sales as mix shifts toward higher-margin digital, ads, and membership.
- Higher-quality revenue streams are scaling fast, with advertising +37% globally, Walmart Connect +41%, and membership income +15%+, which supports margin durability beyond pure retail spread.
- Execution has been consistently solid, with 7 beats and 1 miss in the last 8 reported quarters, including the latest +9.2% EPS beat on 2026-08-20.
- Automation is moving from promise to operating reality, with about 60% of U.S. stores receiving some freight from automated DCs and about 50% of eCommerce FC volume automated, while inventory rose only 2.6% against sales growth near 5%.
Bear Case
- The valuation asks too much: 38.98x P/E on FY2026 EPS of $2.74 and roughly 37.9x-39.3x on FY27 guided EPS of $2.75-$2.85, versus 23.0x peer average.
- Core profitability remains thin for the multiple, with FY2026 operating margin at just 4.3% and net margin 2.9%, while Q4 EBITDA margin was only 5.5%, down 150 bps versus Q3 and 220 bps versus Q2.
- Management flagged a regulatory hit, with maximum fair pricing legislation creating an approximately 100 bps sales headwind for FY27 in pharmacy.
- Balance-sheet and cash-flow quality are not elite relative to valuation, with current ratio 0.77, Debt/EBITDA 1.59, FCF $7.5B, and internal cash-flow quality score only 11/100.
Valuation & Price Target
Engine price target $89.12 (-17.5% vs current), Low confidence.
- P/E Multiple: $45.87 (28% weight)
- P/S Multiple: $125.46 (20% weight)
- Quality-adjusted: $101.07 (20% weight)
- DCF: $106.15 (14% weight)
The quant baseline says HOLD with Low conviction and a $89.12 target. This note leans more negative and rates SELL because the forward setup looks worse than a neutral call implies: Walmart trades at 38.98x trailing earnings and roughly 38x FY27 guided EPS despite only 3.6% FY2026 revenue growth, 2.6% FY2026 EPS growth, and a consolidated operating margin stuck at 4.3%. The balance sheet is fine, not pristine, with Debt/EBITDA 1.59 and a 0.77 current ratio, while the margin story, though real, is still incremental rather than step-change. Sell-side consensus remains Strong Buy (17 buy / 2 hold / 0 sell), but that is low-signal here and looks more like an endorsement of execution than a disciplined read on valuation.
Risk Assessment
Risk score 47/100 (Moderate). The biggest risk to a bearish stance is that Walmart sustains 6%-8% operating income growth and convinces the market that ads, membership, and profitable eCommerce deserve a structurally higher multiple than the 23.0x peer average.
The Bottom Line
Walmart rates SELL, Medium conviction. The company is executing well, the moat is improving, and management has earned credibility, but the stock still discounts too much of that progress at 38.98x earnings and roughly 38x guided FY27 EPS. This is not a call against the business. It is a call against paying a growth-stock multiple for a company still producing 4.3% operating margins and mid-single-digit sales growth. A move closer to the $89.12 base value, or evidence that consolidated margins can rise meaningfully above current levels, would change the view.
Go deeper in the app
Live charts, options analytics, the full earnings-call breakdown, price alerts, and every other stock — updated in real time.
Get Tickr